Every organization we link to: local tourism offices, the state and federal agencies that manage the land, the nonprofits and clubs that keep access open, and the universities doing the research.
West Virginia has roughly 1.5 million acres of public land and a handful of places that carry almost all of the attention. The consequence is that a great deal of very good ground sits nearly empty, usually for one of three reasons: nobody has heard of it, the road in is gated or rough, or it is undeveloped and has nothing to advertise. Those are the places below — of them across regions.
Almost Heaven Swings
The rule that decides most of this
Hatfield-McCoy requires a trail permit for every rider, sold online and through local vendors, with separate resident and non-resident pricing. Riding on undesignated national forest or state land is prohibited. Helmets are required under 18. That is the legal frame, and the middle sentence is the one people get wrong.
So this is not a comparison of two places to ride an ATV. Hatfield-McCoy is where off-highway riding is designated. Forest roads are public roads through timber country, useful for driving a street-legal vehicle to a trailhead, not a substitute for a permitted network. If your machine is not road-legal, they are not your answer.
A real choice remains, because the two deliver different weekends. One is a managed thousand-mile trail system with towns attached. The other is a long day on gravel to reach country you then walk into.
What a Hatfield-McCoy permit buys you
The network is the largest off-highway trail system in the eastern United States: more than a thousand miles laid over former coal lands in southern West Virginia, split into named systems including Rockhouse, Bearwallow, Buffalo Mountain, Pinnacle Creek, Devil Anse, Pocahontas, Indian Ridge, Ivy Branch and Warrior. Nine or more systems carry the traffic.
Difficulty is color-coded, and green systems suit side-by-sides and first-timers. Use that before the trailer ramp comes down; reading a trail's color beats discovering its character halfway in, and it lets a family of mixed skill ride together. Rider-reported conditions and closures show up on Trailforks for West Virginia.
One hazard is specific to this ground. Open mine portals, subsidence and vertical shafts exist across the coalfields, often unmarked and overgrown, and water around old workings can be acidic. Never enter a mine opening you come across.
What the forest roads are actually for
Much of the best access in the state sits at the end of a forest service road: Dolly Sods, Cranberry, Seneca Creek, the Highlands generally. Many are rough, some close seasonally, and a few are hard on a low-clearance car. Forest Road 75 to Bear Rocks is the most notorious in the state.
The appeal is a driving one rather than a riding one. You take a capable street-legal vehicle up gravel to where the walking starts. Check Monongahela National Forest road status first, because a closure turns a long approach into a dead end.
None of it is a place to unload an unregistered machine. Where a forest road is open, it is open to legal road vehicles, and riding off it on undesignated ground is not permitted. The Forest Service is the authority on which roads are open and to what.
Fuel, signal and time on the gravel
Plan fuel stops deliberately in Pocahontas, Randolph, Pendleton and Webster counties. Long stretches have nothing, and what exists may close early or on Sundays. Carry more water and food than the day requires.
Assume no cell service in the Highlands, the wilderness areas, the gorges and the National Radio Quiet Zone. Download offline maps in Gaia, onX or Avenza before you leave a signal, and treat a satellite messenger as reasonable rather than excessive.
Budget more time than the map implies. Sixty road miles can take two hours here, US 219 is the slow spine of the Highlands and often the only option, and gravel is slower still. A forest road day is a full day.
Machines, towns and what changes the answer
Side-by-sides and beginners have the easiest path at Hatfield-McCoy: green systems are built for them. Dirt bikes ride the same permitted network under the same color-coding, and the permit is per rider regardless of machine.
Full-size vehicles are the exception worth planning around. They have designated routes within the system rather than the run of all thousand-plus miles, so check which of the nine-plus systems takes your rig before you trailer it south. The trail organization can tell you before you leave home.
The towns are the feature nothing else matches. Several connected trail towns permit street-legal riding directly to lodging, fuel and restaurants: Gilbert, Man, Matewan and Bramwell, with Gilbert and Man the most organized around the system. Which streets are open to machines is not in this record, so confirm locally.
Basing at Twin Falls rather than camping
Twin Falls Resort State Park in Wyoming County covers 3,776 acres and works as a Hatfield-McCoy basecamp because it sits close to several trail systems while offering conventional lodging. It is one of West Virginia's resort parks, operating a full lodge, with a golf course on the grounds.
Day use costs nothing, since West Virginia charges no admission at its 35 parks or 9 forests; fees attach to camping, cabins, lodge rooms, pools, golf and rentals. Campgrounds and cabins reserve through the state parks system up to a year ahead, and popular parks fill summer and October weekends within days of the window opening. No site counts or rates for Twin Falls appear here, and trailer parking is the detail to ask about.
On a rest day the park has its own walking. Falls Trail runs 1.25 miles, paved as far as Marsh Fork Falls and unpaved onward to Black Fork Falls. Pathfinder is 2.5 miles with about 500 feet of gain, and Poke Hollow runs 3.5 miles to the park's highest point. Pioneer Farm is on the grounds.
The verdict, rider by rider
Anyone who wants to ride an off-highway machine should go to Hatfield-McCoy, and it is not close. That is where riding is designated, the permit takes minutes online, and the color codes and trail towns solve the two problems that wreck riding trips: unknown terrain and no fuel.
Anyone who wants remote gravel in a licensed truck with hiking at the end should head for the Monongahela forest roads, accept the drive time, and check road status first. Autumn travelers there should wear blaze orange from October through January, since hunting dominates public land outside state parks.
Two things this cannot settle: per-system mileage and color breakdown at Hatfield-McCoy, and which forest roads suit which vehicles. The trail organization answers the first; the Monongahela National Forest answers the second, and its alerts page carries closures and forest orders.
Reach people planning this trip
Placement alongside guides for outfitters, guides, shops and lodging.
List your business hereQuestions
can you ride atvs on forest roads in west virginia?
do you need a permit to ride hatfield-mccoy trails?
can you ride full-size vehicles on hatfield-mccoy?
what is the roughest forest road in west virginia?
Read next
Destination · Southern Coalfields
The Hatfield-McCoy Trails
A guide to the Hatfield-McCoy Trails: the individual trail systems, permits, difficulty, ATV-friendly towns and how the network is organised.
8 min read
Guide · Southern Coalfields
Riding the Rockhouse Trail System
How riding Rockhouse works: what the tread is like, the permit every rider needs, the street-legal trail towns it links, and where to sleep.
6 min read · September
Destination · Southern Coalfields
Twin Falls Resort State Park: A Complete Guide
What the state park publishes about Twin Falls Resort State Park: the 1.25-mile Falls Trail, three ridge loops, sunset from Still Run Ridge, and camping.
7 min read · June